5 November 2026 · essay
Counting Without Time
On a cancer figure, a cash book and the future that is booked nowhere
On 7 October, the Dutch news site NU.nl reported that without intervention the Netherlands will count a quarter more cancer diagnoses and cancer deaths in 2045.1 The figures come from a new forecast by the Netherlands Comprehensive Cancer Organisation (IKNL), which runs the national cancer registry. The number of diagnoses rises from just over 136,000 a year to almost 170,000 in 2045. Mortality rises by 24 per cent, from just over 46,000 to just over 57,000 a year. The cause is mainly demographic: there will be more older people, and the age-adjusted risk stays roughly the same.2 Halfway through the article comes the hopeful thread. If by 2032 no young person smokes and only five per cent of adults do, 120,000 diagnoses will be prevented up to 2045. If everyone drinks two glasses of alcohol a week less from 2032 onwards, that saves some 11,500 diagnoses up to 2050.
Read quickly, two large numbers stay in the mind side by side. Read slowly, they turn out not to be in the same unit.
The missing denominator
The forecast is an annual figure. The prevention figures are summed over two decades or more, over different periods and over different types of cancer. Converted, a different picture emerges. Between 2024 and 2045, the baseline scenario implies an estimated 3.4 million diagnoses. The 120,000 is about three and a half per cent of that.3 According to IKNL, the alcohol effect comes down to an average of 427 diagnoses a year.4 Against 136,000 to almost 170,000 diagnoses a year, that is less than three per thousand. IKNL publishes no margins of uncertainty with the forecast, but warns itself that the figures should not be read as exact predictions. An effect of three per thousand disappears in any total.
Smoking is a different matter, and that is where the first distortion lies. The 120,000 concerns lung, bladder and oesophageal cancer only. Lung cancer accounts for 89,000 of it.5 In 2024, just over 14,000 people received that diagnosis.6 Measured over two decades, this is a large share of all lung cancer, and the effect will become visible in the lung cancer figures. NU.nl does not mention the restriction to three types of cancer. The place where the effect is large, lung cancer, thereby disappears behind a summed figure that stands next to the total and sounds large there.
There is a simple rule of thumb for news: the space a subject receives ought to say something about its size. In the article, demography, which explains nearly all the increase, gets a few sentences. Prevention takes up seven of the eighteen paragraphs. That care capacity will become the bottleneck is stated in the opening and in a quotation from IKNL’s chair, Ernst Kuipers. The second half of the piece is about something else.
Who calculates, for whom
The figure of 120,000 is not new. IKNL published it on 8 October 2024, as a calculation of one of the goals of the Dutch Cancer Agenda: five per cent of adults smoking and no young people smoking by 2032.5 That agenda was drawn up within the Dutch Cancer Collective, initiated at the end of 2022 by IKNL, KWF (the Dutch Cancer Society) and the NFK (the Dutch Federation of Cancer Patient Organisations), and it was launched on 27 November 2023.7 The alcohol figure came in January 2026 from a calculation by IKNL with the Trimbos Institute, the Netherlands Institute of Mental Health and Addiction, and health charities including KWF.4 The knowledge institute is thus calculating the effect of an agenda it helped to write. IKNL describes itself as “an independent knowledge institute for oncological and palliative care”, with the mission of reducing the impact of cancer.8
That mixing of roles is enough on its own to chafe. A party that calculates its own goal also determines the horizon, the scenario and the unit in which the outcome is presented. That can be done carefully, and IKNL itself speaks of “at least” 120,000. Yet the choice of a cumulative figure over 22 years is a presentational choice, and it rests with the party that set the goal. For an advocacy organisation that is legitimate. For an institute that presents itself as an independent source of policy information, it is a withdrawal from the capital it lives on. The CPB, the Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis, can credibly cost party manifestos because it does not write them.
The damage does not stop at a single figure. The average reader does not convert. The sceptic does, and turns a discovered embellishment into proof of a broader story: that institutes colour their figures. Then the figures that are sound lose their authority too. In this way the presentation supplies ammunition to everyone who wants to dismiss any prevention measure as paternalism.
McLurg’s law, in time
Why would a knowledge institute sum its figures? It is fighting a well-known distortion. In 1965, Galtung and Ruge described how cultural proximity determines whether an event becomes news.9 British newsrooms circulated a grimmer version, which the sociologist Philip Schlesinger recorded as McLurg’s law: a scale on which a handful of deaths nearby weighs as much as hundreds far away.10 In 2019, Our World in Data showed how far this reaches. In The New York Times and The Guardian, more than two thirds of the coverage of causes of death concerned suicide, homicide and terrorism, which together caused less than three per cent of deaths. Heart disease, responsible for about a third of deaths, received two to three per cent of the attention.11
The same law works for distance in time. A death today weighs more than a hundred in 2045. Prevention therefore starts every political debate from behind. The costs are immediate and visible; the benefit lies decades away and cannot be pointed out in the totals. The cumulative figure tries to bridge that distance in time with size. That is understandable. It merely trades one distortion for another.
A cash book without a future
What is a matter of presentation in the newspaper is a matter of system in the national budget. On 28 September, in a commentary on the annual parliamentary budget debate, the Dutch daily NRC pointed to the central government’s cash-and-commitments accounting.12 In that system, an expense exists only when the money leaves the building. Deferred maintenance costs nothing in such a system, until it costs everything. According to the commentary, the Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management will fall 80 billion euros short in the coming years of what it needs to bring national infrastructure up to standard. NRC argues for accrual accounting with depreciation on the balance sheet, which the Netherlands Court of Audit has advocated for years. A quarter of a century ago, with Gerrit Zalm at the Ministry of Finance, that switch was close, according to the paper. The ministry’s civil servants stopped it.
It is the same mechanism as in the cancer article, now fixed in the way of counting. Elsewhere I have put it like this: deferral looks cheap because the costs of not choosing are booked nowhere as costs.13 The accounts discount the future without anyone deciding to do so.
Visible and anchored
Yet NRC makes it too easy for itself on three points.
First, Dutch municipalities have worked with accrual accounting for decades. Their Budgeting and Accounting Decree (BBV) requires capitalisation and depreciation, permits provisions for major maintenance and obliges a separate section on the maintenance of capital assets.14 Even so, on 1 September 2020 a quay wall collapsed on the Grimburgwal in the centre of Amsterdam.15 Depreciation on historical cost leaves replacement value out of view. A provision can be underfunded for years without the council noticing.
Second, the shortfall on national infrastructure was known. In June 2020 the ministry informed Parliament that an external review had found a shortfall in maintenance funding at Rijkswaterstaat, the national agency for roads and waterways, of around 1 to 1.4 billion euros a year. In December 2020, the validation arrived at an average of one billion a year above the available budget, up to 2035.16 That knowledge simply had no binding place in the decision. The shortfall was never a shortage of knowledge.
Third, the resistance at Finance is less puzzling than the commentary suggests. Since 1994, the Dutch government has applied trend-based budgeting, a fiscal framework built on fixed real expenditure ceilings. The expenditure ceiling counts spending as it appears on the budgets on a cash basis.17 With accruals inside the expenditure ceiling, consumption can be depreciated as investment, creating room that does not exist. The British experience with Gordon Brown’s golden rule shows how elastic the notion of investment becomes as soon as it creates budgetary room. The Institute for Fiscal Studies counted the reclassification of road spending as capital among the moved goalposts.18 The sensible compromise is a balance sheet with depreciation at replacement value for visibility and accountability, alongside an expenditure ceiling that stays on a cash basis.
That moves the problem to where it belongs, without solving it yet. Visibility without an owner becomes a monitor, and the Netherlands has monitors enough. The question is what remains standing when no one is looking any more. Which official, which budget with which duration and which standard will hold the level of maintenance in place when the cabinet falls? In Interim Management for the Public Sector, that is the criterion against which every intervention is ultimately judged.19 An accrual system without an agreed maintenance level and without an owner with a horizon improves the mirror and leaves the decision untouched. Moreover, the proposal confines itself to money, and money is the least constrained of the load-bearing resources. Space, energy, people and decision-making capacity appear on no balance sheet.
The sum
A newspaper figure without a unit of time, a cash book without a future, a budget without a sum: three scales, one distortion. In all three, the future is discounted by the way of counting, without anyone deciding it. The figures already exist. What is missing is a place where they are laid side by side, and someone who puts their signature underneath.
What is not counted is paid for all the same. Only later, by others, and without a sender.
Jacob Huibers is an interim manager with more than twenty years of experience in the Dutch public sector. He has worked as cluster manager, cluster director and kwartiermaker — brought in to stand up new organisations — at municipalities ranging from fifty thousand to over two hundred thousand inhabitants, and at inter-municipal collaborative bodies across the social and physical domains. Statecraft is his platform for strategic reflection on public-sector execution, pillar IV of House of Viridian.
Responses and counter-arguments via Statecraft.nl.
Footnotes
-
Kim Einder, ‘Zonder ingrijpen zijn er over 20 jaar een kwart meer kankerdiagnoses en -doden’, NU.nl, 7 October 2026. ↩
-
IKNL, ‘Aantal kankerdiagnoses stijgt tot 2045 naar bijna 170.000 per jaar’, press release, 7 October 2026, and the accompanying page Kanker in 2045 on iknl.nl. The press release gives 136,000 as the figure for 2025, the page as that for 2024. ↩
-
Own estimate by linear interpolation between the points given by IKNL for 2024 (136,000), 2032 (just over 152,000) and 2045 (almost 170,000). IKNL publishes the annual series in NKR Cijfers. ↩
-
IKNL, ‘Slechts twee glazen alcohol minder per week voorkomt ruim 11.500 kankerdiagnoses tot 2050’, 13 January 2026: 11,529 diagnoses across seven types of cancer, an average of 427 a year, with the Trimbos Institute and health charities of De Gezonde Generatie. ↩ ↩2
-
IKNL, ‘Rookvrije toekomst kan in 22 jaar minstens 120.000 kankerdiagnoses voorkomen’, 8 October 2024: period 2024-2045, lung cancer 89,000, bladder cancer just over 16,000, oesophageal cancer almost 15,000; scenario following one of the goals of the Dutch Cancer Agenda. ↩ ↩2
-
IKNL, cancer figures, 14 August 2025 (provisional): 14,413 lung cancer diagnoses in 2024, cited in Longkanker Nederland, Factsheet Longkanker 2025. ↩
-
Nederlands Kanker Collectief, nederlandskankercollectief.nl; Dutch parliamentary paper Kamerstukken II 32 793, no. 707 (launch of the Dutch Cancer Agenda on 27 November 2023); M. de Leeuw, ‘Impact van kanker reduceren door data te laten leven’ (interview with Thijs Merkx), Oncologie Up-to-date 16 (2025), no. 5. ↩
-
IKNL, ‘Over IKNL’, iknl.nl. ↩
-
Johan Galtung and Mari Holmboe Ruge, ‘The Structure of Foreign News: The Presentation of the Congo, Cuba and Cyprus Crises in Four Norwegian Newspapers’, Journal of Peace Research 2 (1965), no. 1, pp. 64-91. ↩
-
Philip Schlesinger, The social organisation of news production: a case study of BBC radio and television news, PhD thesis, London School of Economics, 1975, pp. 207-208; published in revised form as Putting ‘Reality’ Together (1978). Schlesinger places the anecdote at the BBC External Services; he does not say who McLurg was. ↩
-
Hannah Ritchie, ‘Does the news reflect what we die from?’, Our World in Data, 29 May 2019 (original version; the page was replaced in October 2025 by an updated analysis). Figures for 2016, within thirteen causes of death that together account for about 88 per cent of deaths in the United States. Underlying study: H. Al-Jamaly, M. Siemers, O. Shen and N. Stone, ‘Death: Reality vs Reported’, University of California San Diego, 2018. ↩
-
‘De verouderde financiële gereedschapskist van minister Eelco Heinen helpt Nederland op termijn niet verder’, commentary, NRC, 28 September 2026. ↩
-
From an essay, in preparation, on the sum of Dutch claims on space, energy, people, money and decision-making capacity. ↩
-
Besluit begroting en verantwoording provincies en gemeenten, Articles 9 and 12 (section on the maintenance of capital assets), 44 (provisions), 59 to 64 (capitalisation, valuation and depreciation). ↩
-
AMS Institute, ‘Collapse of Grimburgwal: lessons for the Amsterdam area’, 28 April 2022. ↩
-
Kamerstukken II 35 300 A, no. 94 (19 June 2020) and 35 570 A, no. 46 (17 December 2020). ↩
-
Nota over de toestand van ’s Rijks Financiën, Kamerstukken II 36 600, no. 2 (2024). ↩
-
R. Chote, ‘The macroeconomic framework: time for a tweak?’, Institute for Fiscal Studies, 21 February 2007; R. Chote, C. Emmerson and G. Tetlow, IFS Green Budget, January 2009, chapter 5. ↩
-
Jacob Huibers, Interim Management for the Public Sector: Direction in motion (Dutch: De Richting van de Beweging), manuscript in preparation, chapter 9 (Anchoring and transfer value). ↩